• About
  • Shop
  • Forum
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
e-Paper
Kashmir Thunder - Latest News, Breaking News
Friday, November 20, 2026
  • HOME
  • News
    • Top Headlines
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • Business
  • Science & Tech
  • Education
  • Health
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Feature
    • Review
  • Sports
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Others
  • EPAPER
  • HOME
  • News
    • Top Headlines
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • Business
  • Science & Tech
  • Education
  • Health
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Feature
    • Review
  • Sports
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Others
  • EPAPER
No Result
View All Result
Kashmir Thunder - Latest News, Breaking News
No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
  • Business
  • Science & Tech
  • Education
  • Health
  • Opinion
  • Sports
  • EPAPER

Legal heirs of doctor can be sued in alleged medical negligence case after doctor’s death: SC

by PTI
May 4, 2026
Reading Time: 3 mins read
Legal heirs of doctor can be sued in alleged medical negligence case after doctor’s death: SC
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterWhatsapp

New Delhi, May 4: In a significant verdict which may have wider ramifications, the Supreme Court on Monday held that under the law, the legal heir of a doctor, who is facing any medical negligence case, can be proceeded against after the doctor’s death.

A bench of Justices JK Maheshwari and AS Chandurkar answered a question of law in a more than three-decade-old case, where a doctor, now deceased, had operated on the wife of the complainant (also now deceased) after which she lost her vision.

The top court, which termed the matter as an “exceptional case”, where it has to dredge out older statutory provisions to address the issue, said it was only answering the question on interpretation of the applicable law and not expounding on the normative requirement as to whether the policy adopted by the law applicable is correct or there is a need to change.

The bench said in the context of Rule 4 of Order XXII of CPC, one has to understand and see whether the right to sue against such alleged medically negligent doctor survives or not upon his death.

It said the ‘right to sue’ means the right to seek relief through legal proceedings and such proceedings, in a general sense, are instituted against the opposite party/defendant(s), who possess a corresponding right to defend, as opposed to the claimant’s right to prosecute.

“The right to defend is intrinsically linked to, and arises from, the right to prosecute, and vice versa. Therefore, for the continuation of proceedings, it is essential that both rights co-exist.

“Nonetheless, in view of the preceding discussion and the statutory framework provided in the 1986 Consumer Protection Act as well as the 2019 Consumer Protection Act, we conclude that upon the death of the alleged medically negligent doctor, his/her legal heirs can be impleaded and brought on record.

“Consequently, the extent of liability will be determined based on the pleadings and evidence presented. The question is answered accordingly,” it held.

The top court, which examined several laws, statutes and English law provisions, said the legal question assumes importance as the implication of the holdings in this case would also apply to numerous types of tortious claims, including personal injuries that do not amount to death, including motor vehicle accidents and other industrial accidents.

“In this context, we only state the principle of law as applicable, without considering any additional policy consideration which may be relevant to be considered elsewhere under different enactments,” it said, adding that in posterity, this case may be a lesson to the students and stakeholders to have a strong emphasis on legal history and jurisprudence.

The top court said the law seems to have been lost to the pages of history due to less tort actions being litigated in India.

“We may note that this court herein is only answering the question on interpretation of the applicable law and not expounding on the normative requirement as to whether the policy adopted by the applicable law is correct or there is a need to change. English law appears to have gone further to preserve tortious liabilities of the deceased defendant.

The bench said that even several judgments and the Haryana Law Commission have also taken a view to recommend amendments.

“We feel that it is appropriate to engage policy experts to debate the need and necessity of expanding the scope of Section 306 of the 1925 Indian Succession Act which deals with demands and rights of action of or against deceased survivors to and against the executor or administrator.

“The policy consideration is best left to the Law Commission to see whether there is a need to have a re-look at these provisions for future,” it said.

The complainant initially moved to the district consumer forum, Munger in Bihar, saying that he consulted Dr P B Lall (now deceased) at his private clinic on February 10, 1990, after his wife complained of severe pain in her right eye.

On examination, Dr Lall advised immediate operation, which was done on February 11, 1990, but the pain reoccurred on March 16, 1990, and she was taken back to Dr Lall.

Despite further treatment, there was no relief, and the complainant consulted other doctors at Bhagalpur and Aligarh. As there was no respite, he consulted a doctor at Shankar Netralaya, Madras.

“As alleged, he informed that his wife had already lost vision in the right eye due to wrong treatment and operation, which can further affect the vision in her left eye.

“On the advice of surgery of his wife’s left eye, she was operated on May 5, 1994. Consequently, the complainant had to visit Madras multiple times, and the treatment of his wife with a local doctor continued till August 5, 1997,” the top court noted.

He filed a consumer complaint under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, on August 13, 1997, against Dr Lall for alleged deficiency in service, claiming compensation of Rs 4.5 lakh for his expenses and agony.

During the pendency of the complaint in NCDRC, Dr Lall passed away on August 4, 2009, and the original complainant also died on January 16, 2014.

Previous Post

BJP’s next battlegrounds: UP, Punjab, Goa, Himachal among 7 states

Next Post

=== Special Relief Ration Scheme === Officers visit migrant camps to review ration distribution

PTI

PTI

READ MORE

Sagar calls for time-bound upgradation of Grid Stations

by PTI
November 18, 2026
Sagar calls for time-bound upgradation of Grid Stations

Reviews power infrastructure in Sopore, Baramulla BARAMULLA, NOVEMBER 18: Minister for Revenue, Power Development Department (PDD), Law Justice and Parliamentary affairs, Disaster Management, Relief, Rehabilitation and Reconstruction (DMRRR) and Election, Ali Mohammad...

Read moreDetails

Sakeena Itoo participates in National Social Justice Summit in New Delhi

by PTI
November 18, 2026
Sakeena Itoo participates in National Social Justice Summit in New Delhi

Highlights challenges faced by students in remote areas of J&K NEW DELHI, NOVEMBER 18: Minister for Social Welfare, Health and Medical Education, Sakeena Itoo Wednesday highlighted the geographical, infrastructural and administrative challenges...

Read moreDetails

DC Samba convenes Block Diwas at Birpur- Bari Brahmana

by PTI
November 18, 2026
DC Samba convenes Block Diwas at Birpur- Bari Brahmana

SAMBA, NOVEMBER 18: Deputy Commissioner Samba Dr. Rupesh Kumar Wednesday conducted a Block Diwas here at Panchayat Ghar Birpur Block Bari Brahmana to review developmental issues and take stock of public grievances...

Read moreDetails

Director Agriculture Jammu inaugurates First Harvest of Shiitake Mushrooms

by PTI
November 18, 2026
Director Agriculture Jammu inaugurates First Harvest of Shiitake Mushrooms

JAMMU, NOVEMBER 18: Director Agriculture Production & Farmers Welfare, Jammu Anil Gupta Wednesday inaugurated the first harvest of Shiitake mushrooms (Lentinula edodes) at the Shiitake Development Laboratory of the Spawn Production Office,...

Read moreDetails

District-Level mock exercise on flood water rescue held at Uttri- Kathua

by PTI
November 18, 2026
District-Level mock exercise on flood water rescue held at Uttri- Kathua

xKATHUA, NOVEMBER 18: The District Administration Kathua, in coordination with the 13th Battalion of the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF) and other stakeholder departments, Wednesday conducted a District-Level Mock Exercise on Flood...

Read moreDetails

Haj-2027 : First Phase of orientation programme scheduled for November 23, 25 in Anantnag

by PTI
November 18, 2026

ANANTNAG, NOVEMBER 18: The District Administration Anantnag has scheduled the first phase of the orientation and training programme for selected pilgrims of Haj-1448 (H) 2027 on November 23 and 25, 2026, at...

Read moreDetails

DC Shopian presides over public outreach programme at Sedow

by PTI
November 18, 2026
DC Shopian presides over public outreach programme at Sedow

SHOPIAN, NOVEMBER 18: As part of the government’s sustained efforts to strengthen grassroots-level governance and ensure effective public grievance redressal, a comprehensive Public Outreach Programme was Wednesday organized at GHS, Sedow in...

Read moreDetails

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2025 Kashmir Thunder - Designed by K.Web.

No Result
View All Result
  • HOME
  • News
    • Top Headlines
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • Business
  • Science & Tech
  • Education
  • Health
  • Opinion
    • Editorial
    • Feature
    • Review
  • Sports
    • Cricket
    • Football
    • Others
  • EPAPER

© 2025 Kashmir Thunder - Designed by K.Web.